1) "Graffiti Moon" by Cath Crowley
Alternating narrators and snatches of poetry tell the tale of love among graffiti artists.
Lucy has been searching for the mysterious graffiti artist Shadow, whose work seems to address her fear of romance. Unfortunately, the only guy who knows how to track him down is Ed, whose nose Lucy broke at the end of a disastrous date. Ed knows how to track down Shadow because he is Shadow—a secret he hopes to keep from Lucy while he leads her around town revisiting old haunts. When Lucy discovers that Ed has been lying to her, she must deal with her conflicted feelings over the artist and the annoying man. Readers will quickly realize that Ed and Shadow are one and the same, a fact that Crowley reveals fairly early on. With that mystery stripped away, Ed is difficult to like, lacking both a strong personality and emotional resonance. His difficulty at school due to dyslexia smacks of pandering and isn’t well integrated into the overall story. Lucy’s personality is slightly more developed; glassblowing is a talent not often seen in teen fiction. However, Crowley’s divided narrative doesn’t suit the characters, and the decision to intersperse poems into the mix further fractures their interactions.
There’s splashes of color, but teens will find their interest washes out rapidly. (Fiction. 13 & up)
2) "Once A Witch" by Carolyn MacCullough
3) "The Silver Kiss" by Annette Curtis Klause
4) "A Kiss in Time" by Alex Flinn
Sleeping Beauty wakes up in the 21st century; clichés ensue. When Princess Talia pricks her finger on a spindle on her 16th birthday, she fulfills a curse that puts the entire kingdom of Euphrasia to sleep for centuries. Modern teen Jack, on the lam from a guided bus tour of Europe, discovers the slumbering kingdom and wakes the princess in a decidedly creepy date-rape–like scenario. Both wishing to flee the clutches of the king, they escape together to Jack’s home in Miami, where the girls are either vapid sluts or nerdy brains and the boys are mostly just clueless. The narration shifts between Talia and Jack, but the device sheds little light into their characters; both are too broadly drawn to engage readers. She seems petulant and pampered but turns out to be kind and adaptable; he’s supposedly a slacker, but he’s really brimming with motivation. All too easily they buff away each other’s sharp edges, though their lack of chemistry makes their inevitable declarations of love forced and awkward. There is nothing fresh about this reinterpretation.(Fantasy. 11-14)
5) "Sisters Red" by Jackson Pearce
6) "Inside Out" by Maria V. Snyder
Trella’s world, called Inside, is divided both physically and socially. The upper levels of Inside house the white-collar class, and the lower levels are for laborers. Trella is a scrub, a lower-level resident whose job is to keep Inside clean. Her small stature enables her to travel around Inside via its environmental control system and spy on the Uppers. Then, her only friend enlists her to help hide Broken Man, who claims that he has found the Gateway to the outside world. By accident, Trella becomes the face of a scrub revolution, and she resorts to leading a double life in order to save both her friend and the hope that the Gateway exists. Despite a promising concept, the book fails to grab readers and never gains momentum. Broken Man’s role as the prophet of the revolution is never explained. The peripheral characters exist for their roles in the revolution save for an Upper named Riley, who becomes Trella’s love interest. Too many rushed plotlines about Inside’s history and families plus not enough character development or worldbuilding make for a dull story. (Science fiction. YA)
7) "A Certain Slant of Light" by Laura Whitcomb
What should be a sure-fire ghost story/romance fails to ignite a spark. Helen is a spirit that cleaves to hosts, unsure of why she’s bound to earth. She picks very literary hosts (including Emily Dickinson), such as her current high-school English teacher. It is at school that Helen is “seen” for the first time, by teenager Billy Blake. Turns out Billy is actually “James”—another spirit who’s figured out how to inhabit a body. He and Helen fall in love, and he convinces her to find a body so that they can have sex (semi-graphically depicted, and somehow also coldly so). Their hosts both have troubled homes (one drugs, the other religion, both with messed-up parents), leading to a predictable close. Unsurprising plot, under-developed characters and adequate prose doom this first novel. The love story, and the device of a spirit gaining flesh, should be emotionally rich fodder, yet Whitcomb takes these nowhere. Young women will be drawn to this book, and will probably finish it, but unless the collection needs another forgettable easy-sell, skip it. (Fiction. YA)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.